.png)
For many professional gay men, success is rarely just about the work itself. It is accompanied by a silent, second by second calculation, an invisible tax paid in energy, vigilance, and self editing. We call it masking. While it often starts as a survival mechanism, over time, it becomes the very thing standing between you and the life, health, and leadership impact you actually want.
In psychological terms, masking is the conscious or subconscious suppression of one's authentic traits, mannerisms, or identity markers to blend into dominant cultural expectations.
Masking is not unique to the queer community, however while heterosexual individuals often mask neurodivergence or emotional suppression to fit stoic ideals, masking in the gay community takes on a multi-layered dimension.
It is practiced even after coming out. Gay men frequently monitor their vocal inflections, tone, body language, or references to their personal lives to navigate professional, social, or family settings safely. Masking in the gay community is not a rare exception, it is a systemic baseline.
Research from Stonewall UK’s Workplace Equality Index highlights that almost 40% of LGBTQ+ employees still hide their identity at work, choosing to cover or mask out of fear of professional friction or bias.
Pan-European data from the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) LGBTIQ Surveys demonstrates that millions of queer individuals across Europe routinely alter their behavior or conceal their identities in public and social life to avoid discrimination.
We have to look honestly at why masking is so hard to drop, especially for men moving into senior leadership.
Across all levels of leadership and organizational life whether in an executive meeting, a management team discussion, or the daily rhythm of the work floor canteen the unspoken default template often leans toward a rigid, traditional mold. Whether or not it is explicitly enforced, the perception of that cultural norm is often enough to trigger immediate vigilance.
If you feel you don't match the standard scripts whether it's casual chatter about weekend football, F1, or familiar social rituals the anticipated risk of being overlooked or sidelined becomes entirely real in your own mind, even if it has never openly manifested.
To bridge that gap, many leaders feel compelled to over perform and mimic dominant behaviors just to stay visible. The tragic paradox is that,
the very armor you put on to secure your seat at the table ends up cutting you off from the authentic authority and daily vitality that actually makes you effective.
To be clear, it is not my intention to single out or critique the heterosexual community rather, I want to confront an uncomfortable truth about our own culture. In the gay community itself, certainly as I was growing up and my sense is that it persists today, there is another, often more painful, layer of masking that happens.
For gay men particularly those who are more effeminate, slender, or do not fit the 'masc' mold the pressure to mask often starts inside the very spaces that are supposed to offer saftey and belonging.
Within many gay social and dating spaces, there is a pervasive bias that rewards traditional masculinity while marginalizing or even fetichising those perceived as too effeminate, soft, or somehow non-conforming to the particular 'tribe' they belong to.
When men are implicitly or explicitly told that their natural presentation is "less than," they learn to mask even among peers. This creates a profound double isolation: feeling alienated from mainstream society, yet rejected or overlooked in the very community where we expected unconditional acceptance. This is not in small part contributing to the lonliness epidemic we see pervading the gay community at this time.
In many Latin or Mediterranean environments, this dynamic is amplified by cultural barometers like 'Jidher' in Maltese, he's Visible or tiene pluma in Spanish for example it literally means he has feathers , but in both cases it infers towards the level of how visible 'the gay' or the visible, expressive mannerisms often associated with gay are in an individual.
It operates as an unspoken social grading system, where someone might be judged with phrases like 'tiene mucha pluma' (he has a lot of pluma) versus a dismissive reassurance like 'es gay, pero no tiene mucha pluma' (he's gay, but he doesn't have much pluma). Here, pluma is treated almost as a measure of worth or professional safety, dictating how palatable or 'acceptable' you are allowed to be in a professional space.
As a gay man, I haven't been spared this dynamic. Looking back, it wasn’t so much that I didn’t realize I was doing it, it was that I didn’t realize the extent to which I was doing it.
It had become so thoroughly internalized that it simply felt like normal behavior. I had built a quiet, constant system of self monitoring. I learned to watch my hands, moderate my vocal inflection, and mute my natural gestures without a second thought. It wasn’t confined to business environments or trying to survive a hyper-masculine culture, it bled into everyday life a pervasive vigilance that taught me how to make myself smaller, safer, and entirely unremarkable from a gay community perspective. If possible invisible to the world.
I was in my early twenties, sitting among a group of older peers, men in law practice and architecture whom I deeply looked up to. In the middle of a casual conversation, they delivered a blunt, unvarnished message. In no uncertain terms, I was told that it was flamboyant people like me who 'bring a bad name to the gay community.'
'It’s okay to be gay,' the argument went, 'but do you really need to be so obvious?
'Princesses like you make it hell for the rest of us who just want to be treated like everyone else'.
That conversation left a permanent mark. The directive was clear, assimilation was the price of admission. From that moment on, a pervasive vigilance set in, teaching me how to make myself smaller, safer, and entirely unremarkable, long before I ever stepped foot into a boardroom or an executive meeting.
This is double isolation. When you face that kind of judgment from within the very spaces that are supposed to be safe havens, you learn to pick up the invisible scissors yourself. You start clipping your own 'pluma' and editing your presence just to keep the peace, to make others feel comfortable.
I remember sharing this with a very good girl friend who already then was wise beyond her years and one of the smartest people I have known,
'there is a profound difference between tolerance and acceptance'. She said
Tolerance says, "Be gay, just don't make me look at it."
True acceptance demands something entirely different. If you truly accept me, you accept me with all my pluma. Actually, no, you celebrate me with all my pluma. Truer words have never been spoken.
Today It is easy to dismiss masking as a modern, psychological luxury something we analyze in therapy or coaching sessions but we must not forget our history.
Right here in Spain, in 1936, just before he was murdered, Federico García Lorca left behind a few haunting fragments of an unfinished work titled La Bola Negra (The Black Ball) the story of a young man rejected from a traditional social club because his homosexuality was an open secret. The black balls dropped into the ballot box were a definitive sentence of exclusion. This is a big topic of conversation at the time of writing as a movie has been made that has been rather successful and is up for a best internaltional picture at this year's oscars. If you get a chance go watch it, or even better make the time to go watch it I promise you it will be worth it.
I sat down with men from older gay generations in Spain recently, people who remember the reality of living under the Franco regime first hand, where state sanctioned persecution hunted down anything outside the rigid norm. Many in their 60's and 70s yet still carry full armour today inspite of our much broader freedoms, I realized their armor is so thick and persistant because it wasn't adopted for career advancement or for them to live more authentically. It was installed as part of their identity so that they could literally survive. They built fortress like masks because the alternative was at best unbearable persecution and at worst death.
We should not delude ourselves and think these mechanisms of exclusion are confined to history. Hearing accounts of individuals escaping active persecution in modern authoritarian regimes reminds me daily that state sanctioned terror against queer lives is not a ghost of the past it is happening right now, today as you are reading this.
When you trace that lineage from the shadows of history to those fleeing modern persecution it should at least, completely reframe our daily compromises.
It also exposes the tragic irony of our own internal bullying. When those of us who inherit hard won freedoms turn around and use invisible scissors to clip each other's 'pluma', whether through the way we behave on dating apps or in real world spaces, we are effectively blackballing our own people. Instead of building a genuine alliance for everyone’s safety and freedom, we end up enforcing the very conformity that shackles us all.
Yet, it is not all gloom, even as we navigate the weight of these compromises, there is hope to be found. We must first acknowledge the many individuals who, through hard work and against the grain effort, are actively carving out genuine safe spaces refuges for all of us who have ever felt left out, or even betrayed, by both society at large and our own community.
I was reminded of one such example recently when I encountered Fabri Orlandi and Sergio Toyos. Through the #Orlander community, they and their teams are doing an extraordinary job building environments that are intentionally alcohol and drug free, fostering healthy connections, and inspiring a return to true vitality where anyone can belong and find a place to heal through sports, dance and psychological support in the form of an educational platform as well as dedicated workshops inside the community lead by professionals.
From those safe foundations, we can see the weight of the mask and the power of dropping it across every major arena of public life. In entertainment, figures like Jonathan Van Ness refused to sanitize their natural expressiveness to cross over into mainstream success, proving that unapologetic authenticity makes a public presence magnetic rather than diminished.
Move into the hyper-masculine world of elite sports, and the stakes rise exponentially; yet, trailblazers like Carl Nassib stepped out from behind the protective armor of silence in the NFL, shattering the archaic myth that professional excellence requires hiding who you are. Even at the absolute pinnacle of global corporate leadership, executives like Apple CEO Tim Cook dismantled the traditional firewall between personal identity and corporate power, proving that true authority is rooted in transparency, not concealment.
Across industries, the lesson remains the same:
the energy required to maintain the mask always extracts a tax on your vitality, while stepping out from behind it unlocks your true power.
Unmasking is a deliberate, courageous choice to drop that armor. It is the reclamation of energy spent on hyper vigilance, aligning your external expression with your internal truth so you can return to true health and authenticity but it is by no means an easy task or for that matter universally possible.
Understanding the history, the emotional tax, and the intra-community bullying is necessary, but diagnosis is not the final destination. The real work begins the moment you decide that survival is no longer enough and you feel safe enough in the space you inhabit to take that very first incredibly brave step out into the light.
True unmasking begins when you actively notice the micro adjustments you make throughout the day holding your breath, flattening your gestures and consciously choose to release them. Your nervous system finally receives the signal that it is safe to rest, restoring your baseline physical and mental health.
It means picking up your 'pluma', dusting off your natural grace, and refusing to apologize for taking up space.
When you drop the armor and lead life from your authentic self, everything shifts, energy is unlocked for your vitality, the loneliness of being loved only for your performance dissolves into genuine belonging, and your presence becomes grounded and unshakeable.
When I first started The Culture Gardener and began building my coaching practice, I was constantly told to find my niche to look far and wide for that specific market or angle that mattered most. So I searched. I looked outward, I even masked to some extent trying to see where I could fit in instead of listening to my heart and accept the place I can make the biggest impact and stand out.
It took me a long time to realize what was right in front of me, perhaps because unmasking isn’t a single, cinematic act of great courage, but a quiet, gradual journey.
It was only when I finally unmasked myself, when I learned to tend to my own health, protect my own vitality, and actively work on belonging that I found my way home and my true peace.
I had to learn that whilst belonging might be a natural state, it needs nurturing and in the end participation is a choice.
Through self love, coaching, intentional inner work, and the right choices along the way, I found a path to growth. I realized that the best place I can have the most impact is right here, in my own community. It is the space I understand, the nuances I feel in my bones, and the people I relate to best.
If you have come this far in reading this you might be recognizing the weight of your own armor, take a deep breathe and sit with it for a moment, listen to it. it's OK.
If you are tired of performing, editing your presence, or carrying the double isolation of keeping up appearances just so that others can feel comfortable, know that unmasking is a journey and you don't have to navigate that journey alone.
You weren't meant to carry the weight of a performance forever. Your feathers were never a liability, they are your strength, your superpower.
If you’re ready to put down the armor, restore your health, reclaim your vitality, and choose to act on true belonging, let’s talk. The first call is on me Reach out to book a free, no obligation first discovery call, and let’s explore what unmasking looks like for you.
References
Stonewall News Release on Workplace Identity and Masking Statistics
Gesis Archive Entry for the EU LGBTI Survey (Dataset & Reports)
A note on Transparency: The insights, lived experiences, personal reflections, and core frameworks in this article belong entirely to me. I utilize AI tools as a sounding board, research assistant, and copy editor to help organize my thoughts and refine the text allowing me to focus fully on the human truth, coaching philosophy, and authentic message behind my work.
